Ketogenic Diet or Carnivore Diet: Which Diet Is Hurting Your Heart More?

Updated Dec 30, 2024 | 01:03 PM IST

SummaryDiet trends pop up and die off as quickly as they rise to fame. Most of them have a short-term goal in mind like quick weight loss or bulk-up, ignoring how it may affect your body in the long run. Similarly, there has been a lot of debate about two diets, keto and Carnivore.
Keto Vs Carnivore Diet (Credit-Canva)

Keto Vs Carnivore Diet (Credit-Canva)

Amidst the constant stream of diet trends, it's really important to prioritize health over quick fixes. Many people will follow diet trends they find on social media and follow it, ignoring how it may affect their health later in life. While eliminating sugary drinks and processed foods can be beneficial, you must remember that you are cutting out a big chunk of macronutrient groups, which can lead to nutritional deficiencies and health problems. Then we have the carnivore diet, an extreme version of the ketogenic diet, which eliminates carbohydrates entirely, relying solely on animal products for sustenance. This approach raises significant concerns regarding heart health.

Dangers of Zero Carbs

Having a carnivore diet means complete elimination of carbohydrates, even the ones that have proven health benefits. Many animal products consumed on this diet are high in saturated fat and cholesterol and eliminating plant-based foods which are the primary source of fiber, you are hindering the body's ability to regulate cholesterol and blood pressure. This lack of fiber can also negatively impact gut health, which has broader implications for overall well-being.

Increased Risk of Cardiovascular Issues

We all know that high blood pressure, high cholesterol, diabetes, and obesity are known risk factors for heart disease. While the carnivore diet's restriction of sugar and refined carbohydrates may initially prevent blood sugar spikes, the potential for increased saturated fat and cholesterol intake poses a significant threat. Studies show that increased consumption of red meat and poultry can elevate the risk of high blood pressure in people. Similarly, diets high in saturated fat can raise LDL cholesterol levels, further increasing the risk of heart disease. Therefore, the carnivore diet, while potentially leading to short-term weight loss, may significantly compromise long-term cardiovascular health.

Protecting Your Heart Through Dietary Choices

Maintaining heart health doesn't necessitate eliminating meat entirely, but it does require mindful consumption of saturated fat, you must remember that indulging once in a while does not mean you are no longer taking care of yourself, but the end must justify the process, so try eating a controlled amount. Health organizations recommend limiting saturated fat intake to a small percentage of daily calories. This basically translates to a relatively small amount for most individuals.

Beyond Saturated Fat: Other Dietary Considerations

While saturated fat is a cause of concern, there are other dietary factors that play a crucial role in heart health. Added sugar and sodium can also negatively impact cardiovascular well-being, doctors often discourage people from consuming too much of both as they aid in unhealthy weight gain or high blood pressure. Limiting added sugar intake to a small percentage of daily calories is recommended. Similarly, reducing sodium consumption by substituting processed foods with natural alternatives can contribute significantly to heart health.

Embracing a Heart-Healthy Lifestyle

From the research and studies, we understand that having a more balanced diet, which includes fiber-rich foods like nuts, fruits, vegetables, and whole grains is essential for maintaining heart health. Try aiming for a daily intake of at least 30 grams of fiber and you will see how it can significantly benefit cardiovascular function. Another thing that is equally important is incorporating regular physical activity. Finding enjoyable forms of movement, whether it is a social sports or activities you find pleasurable like dancing, can make exercise a sustainable and positive part of a heart-healthy lifestyle, people often find that dragging yourself to places you do not like does not work long term. With this holistic approach of combining a balanced diet with regular exercise, you will get the best protection for long-term cardiovascular well-being.

End of Article

Eggs Vs Soybean: Which Is More Nutritious As Kolkata’s Midday Meal Scheme Goes Fully Vegetarian

Updated Jun 30, 2026 | 05:00 PM IST

SummaryAmid Kolkata's midday meal row, we find that even though soybean is a decent source of protein, it cannot dethrone eggs for valid reasons.
Eggs Vs Soybean: Nutritionist Reacts As Kolkata’s Midday Meal Scheme Adopts Complete Vegetarianism

Credit: AI-generated image

The West Bengal government’s recent move to substitute eggs with soybean, paneer, and other vegetarian sources in Kolkata’s midday meal scheme has been met with mixed responses. Amid concern for protein deficiency in children, we took a deeper look into the eggs vs soybean debate.

Eggs Vs Soya: Which Is Better?

After the International Society for Krishna Consciousness (ISKCON) took over midday meal duties in Kolkata, it switched to an all-vegetarian diet that entailed removing eggs. The move sparked a debate about the efficacy of vegetarian sources of protein, especially plant-based ones like soybean.

Experts believe that it's not a matter of one food vs the other but understanding the distinct nutritional benefits of each.

HealthandMe spoke to Dr. Aaryin Memon, Clinical Nutritionist, Bhailal General Amin Hospital, Vadodara, about the impact of relying on soybean for protein instead of eggs.

Dr Memon says that protein is one of the key nutrients during childhood and plays a role in the growth, development of muscles, immunity, and brain function. She says that eggs and soybeans are both good sources of protein, but they have different nutritional profiles and impact on the body.

As we have always been told that eggs are the gold standard when it comes to protein for the following reasons:

  • Eggs contain all nine essential amino acids in highly available forms.

  • Eggs are packed with vitamin B12 and vitamin D.

  • Eggs also contain choline, selenium, and healthy fats.

Read more: Frequent Headaches: When To See A Doctor And Warning Signs To Watch For

Additionally, eggs are important for growing children as they contribute significantly in all-round development.

The expert says, “They contain a great amount of choline, which is essential for brain development, memory, and learning.”

When it comes to vegetarian sources of protein that match the nutritional value of eggs, soybeans are one of the top on the list. It is an excellent source of protein, dietary fibre, iron, calcium, magnesium, and beneficial plant compounds including isoflavones.

Soya can also help satisfy children's nutritional requirements and is a recommended vegetarian source of protein, according to nutritionists. It is also inexpensive, readily available, and appropriate for egg-free children's diets due to dietary, religious, or cultural preferences.

But the nutritionist points out that there are differences in their nutritional profiles.

Dr Memon says, “Soybean is a good source of protein, but plant protein is less bioavailable than animal protein. Certain nutrients like vitamin B12 are not found in plant-based protein sources. Additionally, the iron found in soya does not get absorbed in the body as well as iron from animals.”

Soybeans’ comparatively weaker nutritional profile is the reason why vegetarians have to rely on a diverse range of high protein foods like pulses, dairy products, legumes, nuts and seeds, as well as foods rich in vitamin C to support iron absorption, like fruit and vegetables.

This brings us to the conclusion that school meal programmes should embrace an 'either-or' option and include eggs and well-planned vegetarian options where possible. This enables children to have the right kind of nutrition and takes into account differences in their diets.

End of Article

US Gastroenterologist Shares 5 Hidden Causes Of Chronic Heartburn And Bloating

Updated Jun 24, 2026 | 11:53 AM IST

SummaryDr Saurabh Sethi, a Harvard-trained gastroenterologist, debunked the myth that spicy foods cause heartburn and bloating. He revealed five recurring habits that lead to acid reflux.
US Gastroenterologist Shares 5 Hidden Causes Of Chronic Heartburn And Bloating

Credit: iStock

Heartburn and bloating are common indicators of indigestion. According to the US National Institute of Health, more than one billion people worldwide suffer from heartburn and related acid reflux, while nearly 18 per cent of the global population suffers from chronic bloating weekly.

Spicy foods are commonly blamed for heartburn and bloating; however, Dr Saurabh Sethi, a Harvard-trained gastroenterologist, has debunked this myth by claiming five recurring habits that he has seen common amongst such patients in his vast years of experience.

Addressing these underlying issues may help improve symptoms before turning to additional medications, he said, in an Instagram Post.

  • Not enough fiber in the diet

Topping the list is a problem that affects a large portion of adults: inadequate fiber intake.

Fiber plays a critical role in maintaining a healthy gut microbiome and supporting regular digestion.

”A fiber-depleted gut feeds the wrong microbes, leading to excess gas and bloating,” Dr. Sethi said. The daily fiber intake target for an adult should be between 25 and 38 grams, which most adults fail to meet.

  • Chronic stress

The connection between mental health and digestive health is stronger than many people realize.

The gastroenterologist stated that the gut-brain axis, the communication network linking the digestive system and the brain, is real, and stress can alter gut motility, increase symptom perception, and worsen both bloating and reflux.

  • Wrong use of Peppermint

Peppermint tea is a naturally caffeine-free herbal infusion made from leaves of the peppermint plant, widely enjoyed to soothe digestion and reduce bloating.

However, it can cause the opposite of treating bloating by relaxing the lower esophageal sphincter and worsen heartburn.

“You may be treating one symptom while triggering another,” said the specialist, who has performed over 1000 endoscopies.

Read More: FSSAI Tightens Food Safety Norms, Mandates Food-Grade Knives, Cutting Tools

  • Lying down after the meals

Another common habit among patients with chronic heartburn is lying down shortly after meals.

The doctor explained that gravity is the best antacid, and lying down within 2 to 3 hours of eating can cause heavy acid reflux. Dr. Sethi claims that he sees this pattern in chronic heartburn patients every week.

  • Eating too fast

Many people rush through meals without realizing the impact it can have on digestion. One of the biggest contributors to bloating is swallowed air, which increases significantly when people eat too quickly.

"Your stomach isn't a trash compactor," said the gastroenterologist. He also talked about how fast eaters swallow significantly more air than slow eaters.

Dr Sethi said that for people struggling with chronic heartburn and bloating, the solution may not always involve eliminating spicy foods or adding another medication.

End of Article

Eating Toxin-Tainted Seafood May Pose Serious Health Risks: Study

Updated Jun 24, 2026 | 07:00 AM IST

SummaryFoodborne diseases linked to fish and shellfish are increasing worldwide. CDC data from 2011–2023 identified 402 marine toxin outbreaks, causing 1,280 illnesses, 96 hospitalizations, and one death in the United States.
Eating Toxin-Tainted Seafood May Pose Serious Health Risks: Study

Credit: AI Generated Image

From the United States to India, the problem of food-borne diseases is constantly on the rise. The Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report found that 402 US foodborne disease outbreaks were caused by marine toxins in fish and shellfish over the last 23 years, and the researchers also revealed that foodborne diseases caused 1,280 illnesses, 96 hospitalizations, and one death.

The research team from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) and the Oak Ridge Institute for Science and Education parsed data from the CDC’s Foodborne Disease Outbreak Surveillance System (FDOSS) from 2011 to 2023. The data have been provided voluntarily by the local state and health authorities to FDOSS through the CDC’s National Outbreak Reporting System since 2009.

Improper storage of fish at uncontrolled temperatures can lead to the formation of histamine, a compound that may trigger allergic reactions in people. It can also promote the production of scombroid toxins by bacteria that contain the highly active enzyme histidine carboxylase. In addition, other marine toxins may originate from algae and accumulate in fish and shellfish through the food chain, occur naturally in certain fish species, or arise from as-yet unidentified sources.

The authors of the study said that marine toxins cause most of the noninfectious outbreaks reported to FDOSS each year. They also wrote, “Marine toxins that cause foodborne illness are tasteless, odorless, resistant to cooking or freezing, and can produce a complex variety of gastrointestinal, neurologic, and neuropsychologic symptoms.” Then added, “Among persons with severe illness resulting from ingestion of marine toxins, cardiovascular and respiratory manifestations can result in hospitalization and death.”

FSSAI Introduces Stricter Quality Checks For Seafood

The contamination through seafood has also compelled the Food Safety and Standards Authority of India (FSSAI) to bring forth a stricter quality check for them. Recently, India’s food regulator has introduced new safety standards across a wide range of foods, and one of them was seafood, such as prawns.

The draft regulations by the Food Safety and Standards Authority of India (FSSAI) cover heavy metals, toxins, antibiotic residues, and quality standards for both commonly used foods and emerging edible products, the Times of India reported. The new regulations are expected to come into force on December 1.

Also Read: UK Met Office Warns of 'Pollen Bomb': What Hay Fever Patients Need to Know

Notably, the FSSAI's new safety standards will also apply to a wide range of foods, such as besan or gram flour, edible and cold-pressed seed oils.

In a separate draft notification, the FSSAI proposed quality and safety standards for lesser-used edible oils made from chilli, tomato, muskmelon, and okra seeds as demand rises for cold-pressed oils, seed-based snacks, and plant-based nutrition products.

The draft rules also cover edible seeds such as watermelon, cucumber, pumpkin, sunflower, sesame, and flaxseed sold in raw, roasted, or salted forms, requiring them to be clean and free from insects, fungus, and visible contamination before sale.

End of Article