Keto Vs Carnivore Diet (Credit-Canva)
Amidst the constant stream of diet trends, it's really important to prioritize health over quick fixes. Many people will follow diet trends they find on social media and follow it, ignoring how it may affect their health later in life. While eliminating sugary drinks and processed foods can be beneficial, you must remember that you are cutting out a big chunk of macronutrient groups, which can lead to nutritional deficiencies and health problems. Then we have the carnivore diet, an extreme version of the ketogenic diet, which eliminates carbohydrates entirely, relying solely on animal products for sustenance. This approach raises significant concerns regarding heart health.
Having a carnivore diet means complete elimination of carbohydrates, even the ones that have proven health benefits. Many animal products consumed on this diet are high in saturated fat and cholesterol and eliminating plant-based foods which are the primary source of fiber, you are hindering the body's ability to regulate cholesterol and blood pressure. This lack of fiber can also negatively impact gut health, which has broader implications for overall well-being.
We all know that high blood pressure, high cholesterol, diabetes, and obesity are known risk factors for heart disease. While the carnivore diet's restriction of sugar and refined carbohydrates may initially prevent blood sugar spikes, the potential for increased saturated fat and cholesterol intake poses a significant threat. Studies show that increased consumption of red meat and poultry can elevate the risk of high blood pressure in people. Similarly, diets high in saturated fat can raise LDL cholesterol levels, further increasing the risk of heart disease. Therefore, the carnivore diet, while potentially leading to short-term weight loss, may significantly compromise long-term cardiovascular health.
Maintaining heart health doesn't necessitate eliminating meat entirely, but it does require mindful consumption of saturated fat, you must remember that indulging once in a while does not mean you are no longer taking care of yourself, but the end must justify the process, so try eating a controlled amount. Health organizations recommend limiting saturated fat intake to a small percentage of daily calories. This basically translates to a relatively small amount for most individuals.
While saturated fat is a cause of concern, there are other dietary factors that play a crucial role in heart health. Added sugar and sodium can also negatively impact cardiovascular well-being, doctors often discourage people from consuming too much of both as they aid in unhealthy weight gain or high blood pressure. Limiting added sugar intake to a small percentage of daily calories is recommended. Similarly, reducing sodium consumption by substituting processed foods with natural alternatives can contribute significantly to heart health.
From the research and studies, we understand that having a more balanced diet, which includes fiber-rich foods like nuts, fruits, vegetables, and whole grains is essential for maintaining heart health. Try aiming for a daily intake of at least 30 grams of fiber and you will see how it can significantly benefit cardiovascular function. Another thing that is equally important is incorporating regular physical activity. Finding enjoyable forms of movement, whether it is a social sports or activities you find pleasurable like dancing, can make exercise a sustainable and positive part of a heart-healthy lifestyle, people often find that dragging yourself to places you do not like does not work long term. With this holistic approach of combining a balanced diet with regular exercise, you will get the best protection for long-term cardiovascular well-being.
Credits: Canva
Sugar often carries a negative image, but from a nutrition point of view, it is important to separate excess intake from complete avoidance. The human body relies on glucose, a basic form of sugar, as one of its primary energy sources. Muscles, the brain and red blood cells all need a steady supply of glucose to function properly. While the body does not require added or refined sugar, it does need carbohydrates that can be converted into glucose to support metabolism, brain activity and physical movement.
Complex carbohydrates such as whole grains, fruits, vegetables and legumes meet these needs well, as they provide long-lasting energy along with essential nutrients. To understand this balance better, we spoke to Komal Malik, Head Dietician at Asian Hospital, Faridabad, who shared why cutting out sugar entirely may not be the healthiest choice.
Not all sugars act the same way in the body. Natural sugars found in fruits, vegetables and dairy come packaged with fibre, vitamins, minerals and antioxidants. As Komal Malik explains, this natural combination slows digestion and absorption, helps keep blood sugar levels stable and promotes a feeling of fullness.
On the other hand, refined or added sugars are commonly found in sweets, baked items, sugary drinks and processed foods. These sugars are absorbed rapidly, offering quick calories with little nutritional benefit. Komal said, “Regular high intake of refined sugar has been linked to metabolic imbalance, weight gain, insulin resistance and a higher risk of chronic conditions such as type 2 diabetes and heart disease.”
Eliminating all forms of sugar, including naturally occurring sugars, is neither required nor advisable for most people. Very restrictive diets that severely cut carbohydrates or sugar can lead to low energy levels, headaches, irritability, poor focus and reduced physical performance.
Komal Malik points out that since glucose plays a key role in brain function, drastically limiting it may affect mental sharpness and mood. Although the body can adapt to alternative energy sources in specific situations, for the general population, long-term health does not depend on strict and total sugar avoidance.
Beyond physical effects, extreme restriction of sugar can also affect mental and emotional wellbeing. Labeling certain foods as completely forbidden often increases cravings and raises the risk of overeating or binge episodes. This cycle of restriction followed by indulgence can disrupt eating patterns and foster an unhealthy relationship with food. As Komal Malik notes, in clinical nutrition, sustainability matters most. Diet plans that are too rigid are rarely followed in the long run and often do more harm than good.
Moderation, rather than elimination, remains the most practical path to good health. Reducing intake of refined and added sugars while continuing to include natural sugars from whole foods supports steady blood sugar levels and overall nutritional balance. Emphasis should be placed on adequate fibre, sufficient protein and healthy fats, which help control appetite and prevent sharp spikes in glucose. With mindful choices and balance, sugar can be part of a healthy diet without the need to cut it out completely.
Credits: iStock
Have you been drinking milk all your life and suddenly your gut cannot tolerate it? Are you also finding out that you are suddenly lactose intolerant, and trying to find the reason? Nutritionist Sonia Narang might have the answer.
In a podcast with Raj Shamani, Narang decodes Indian diet and its benefits and risks, if not consumed correctly. This is when Raj Shamani throws the question of lactose intolerance, especially when someone like him has been drinking milk since childhood and can no longer tolerate it.
Also Read: Fact Check: Is Weight Lifting Safe for Teens? An Expert Explains the Risks and Safer Alternatives
Narang first explains what lactose is and how it works in one's body. She starts with explaining lactase, which is a sugar found in milk, and digested by lactase, an enzyme found in small intestine.
She then explains that in small intestine, there are brush like formations, called villi, which further have smaller brush called microvilli. This is where lactase is made. This is what helps the breakdown of lactose.
However, she explains, overtime, whether due to age, or infection, lifestyle, bad food choices, the ability of microvilli to produce lactase decreases. She points out that as kids, the production of lactase is enough, due to less exposure to bad food choices.
Lactose intolerance is not an allergy. There are ways to manage or improve lactose intolerance. Narang says that the first step is to eliminate milk completely, and then start with having curd as alternative. "While curd is a dairy product, it already has bacteria that makes it pre-digested," she points out.
She also recommends to slowly introduce milk, "just two spoons between the meals". Since milk is consumed with food, it will digest slowly and by the time it reaches the intestine, small intestine will get the time to produce enough amounts of lactase to digest two spoons of milk, she points out.
Read: 5 Cow’s Milk Substitutes—And What To Look For Before You Buy
As per the NHS, UK, lactose intolerance is when you get symptoms like stomach ache after eating food containing lactose, a sugar found in dairy products.
Dairy products include:
Many processed foods can also contain lactose, including:
Note: Health and Me does not promote any changes to be made in your diet. Always consult your nutritionist or dietitian and your doctor before changing your diet. This piece is based on publicly available content.
Credits: iStock/Canva
Chia seeds, a superfood as we all know and have a number of benefits, however, if not taken properly, it can increase risks and could worsen your health, says Dr Shubham Vatsya, a gastroenterologist, and hepatologist at Fortis Vasant Kunj. He is known for making health related content on his Instagram page, targeting foods and habits that impact gut health, liver, and more.
In one of the videos which garnered over one million views, he talks about the risk of chia seeds. The video is titled 'Chia Seeds Are Not For Everyone".
Dr Vatsya points out that if chia seeds are consumed without knowing how your body works and without proper hydration, it could worsen your health.
Talking about who should be more careful before making chia seeds part of their diets? He gives four instances:
He says many people, especially many women have low blood pressure and they may have included chia seeds in their diet without knowing much about it. Why does this happen? Chia seeds contain quercetin, which is an antioxidant and it could reduce your risk of several health condition, including heart diseases. However, points out Dr Vatsya, it is high in fiber, which could further lower your blood pressure. If you already have a low blood pressure, this could cause you a health risk.
Doctor says that people who are on blood thinning medicines like aspirin, especially after a heart stent, may be at risk. Why? Because chia seeds can have a blood thinning effect due to its omega-3 fatty acids content. This can increase bleeding risk. So, people on prescription blood thinners or anticoagulants like warfarin or aspirin, must avoid it.
Chia seeds are high in fiber, which is why it is important to maintain enough hydration. What happens if you do not keep yourself hydrated enough?
While getting enough fiber helps prevent and manage constipation, however, the doctor points out consuming significant amounts of fiber can cause digestive issues like gas, bloating, and abdominal pain, if not hydrated.
Hydration is the key, this is what supports bowel movement regularity and prevent any adverse effects. Furthermore, one should always add fiber to their diet in small amounts and gradually.
Read: Hair Loss In Men: Is It Related To Sweetened Drinks?
Lastly, the doctor says that while chia seeds are healthy, but individuals with chronic kidney disease must be careful while consuming.
Chia seeds are rich in potassium and phosphorous. In per 2.5 tablespoon of serving, it contains 115 mg of potassium and 244 mg of phosphorous. Both these nutrients are closely monitored in people with kidney disease. Chia seeds are also high in oxalate, which can attach to calcium to form kidney stones. This is why it is important to maintain your hydration while consuming chia seeds.
Note: This is a user-generated content via Dr. Shubham Vatsya. Health and Me does not take responsibility of the content. Always consult a registered nutritionist or dietitian and your doctor before making changes to your diet.
© 2024 Bennett, Coleman & Company Limited