Using BMI To Classify People As Obese Is Flawed Say Experts

Updated Jan 16, 2025 | 11:57 AM IST

SummaryBMI is used to classify individuals as underweight, healthy weight, overweight, or obese based on their height and weight. It is calculated by dividing weight in kilograms by health in meters squared. However, there are reasons while it falls short.
BMI Not the right way to measure obesity

A new report published in The Lancet Diabetes & Endocrinology challenges the conventional definition of obesity, and urges a shift from the reliance on Body Mass Index (BMI) to a more nuanced approach. This is supported by over 50 global medical experts. The report also recommends splitting the term "obesity" into two categories: "Clinical obesity" and "Pre-clinical obesity". This aims to improve diagnosis and treatment for over a billion people worldwide living with obesity.

Clinically Obese

This applies to individuals whose obesity has progressed to a disease state, manifesting in organ damage, heart disease, type 2 diabetes, or other health complications. These individuals could also experience symptoms like breathlessness, joint pain, or impaired daily functioning. Treatment also involves medical interventions, including weight-loss medications or surgery.

Pre-Clinic Obese

Whereas the term "pre-clinic obese" refers to those who are overweight but not yet exhibiting health issues. While they may be at risk of developing obesity-related conditions, their organ function and overall health remain intact. What they need is preventive care, which includes dietary guidance, counselling, and regular monitoring to avoid and reduce future health risks.

What does the study say?

The study, led by Professor Francesco Rubino from King's College London emphasizes that obesity is not one-size-fits-all condition. This means it should rather be treated as a spectrum as some individuals maintain normal organ function despite being classified as obese. There are others who may face severe health complications too. However, the current method of calculating obesity based on BMI often leads to misdiagnosis or inadequate care.

The report also states that BMI, while is useful for analyzing population trends, is a flawed unit of measuring individual health. Therefore, there is a need to redefine obesity, and healthcare professionals can provide more precise care by distinguishing those who need immediate medical intervention and those who require preventive strategies.

Limitations of BMI, Why It Falls Short?

BMI is used to classify individuals as underweight, healthy weight, overweight, or obese based on their height and weight. It is calculated by dividing weight in kilograms by health in meters squared. However, there are reasons while it falls short.

•Muscle vs Fat: Athletes or muscular individuals often have high BMIs despite the low body fat

•Fat Distribution: BMI does not measure fat around the waist or organs, which could be more dangerous to one's health.

•Individual Health Variation: It also overlooks the specific health conditions such as heart diseases or diabetes, or any other, while evaluating a person's category in terms of weight.

ALSO READ: Is It Time To Say Goodbye To BMI?

Scope Of Study

By redefining obesity, the study could transform the approach to diagnosis and treatment. It can focus on individual health risks rather than BMI alone. Healthcare providers can also offer tailored care. This also will ensure hat weight-loss medications like Wegovy or Mounjaro are prescribed only to those who genuinely require it.

As per Professor Louise Baur from the University of Sydney, a Children's obesity expert said that this redefinition allows both adults and children to receive more appropriate care while reducing over-diagnosis and unnecessary treatments.

End of Article

Breathing Made Easy Again: Removing Tumour Blocking Airway Through Advanced Bronchoscopy

Updated Nov 21, 2026 | 03:00 PM IST

SummaryAdvanced bronchoscopy techniques can help reopen airways blocked by tumours, restoring airflow and easing breathing difficulties. Explore how these minimally invasive procedures work, who may benefit and their role in improving quality of life for cancer patients.
Breathing Made Easy Again: Removing Tumour Blocking Airway Through Advanced Bronchoscopy

Credit: AI

Doctors have reached a major milestone in minimally invasive lung care. They have removed a suspected endobronchial carcinoid tumor from a patient's airway without needing to perform open chest surgery. The procedure combined four advanced bronchoscopic techniques to successfully remove the tumour while saving the patient’s lung tissue.

A 40 year old male patient from Gurugram came in with breathlessness. Additional examinations revealed partially obstructing the airway and interfering with the patient’s normal breathing. Because of where the tumour was and what it looked like, doctors decided to do the advanced bronchoscopic procedure rather than a more invasive surgery.

Also read: Is It Just A Persistent Cough Or Is Your Body Telling You Something Else?

Endobronchial carcinoid tumours are slow growing but highly vascular and can bleed profusely when excised. Precise instrumentation, careful planning and efficient control of bleeding are required to treat them within the narrow air passage. To overcome these challenges the team employed a multimodality approach that included flexible fibreoptic bronchoscopy to access and visualise the tumour, electrocautery to cut and debulk the growth, Argon Plasma Coagulation (APC) to seal blood vessels and control bleeding and cryotherapy to freeze and extract tumour tissue and treat the residual base.

The combined approach allowed the team to completely remove the tumour and restore airway patency with no need for an external incision. The patient [recovered well and was discharged within X days/is recovering well], while the excised tissue has been sent for histopathological examination to confirm the diagnosis.

Endobronchial tumours such as carcinoids can bleed heavily, so every step has to be planned in advance. By combining electrocautery, argon plasma coagulation and cryotherapy through a flexible bronchoscope, we were able to remove the tumour completely while keeping bleeding under control. For carefully selected patients, this approach can avoid open surgery and the loss of healthy lung tissue.

Traditionally, some endobronchial tumours have required surgical removal of the affected portion of the lung. Advances in interventional pulmonology are expanding treatment possibilities, allowing appropriately selected patients to undergo tumour removal through the natural airway. This approach can help avoid external incisions as well as reduce post procedure pain, shorten hospital stays and support faster recovery.

This achievement shows just how important advanced therapeutic bronchoscopy has become for treating complex airway conditions.

End of Article

Why Are Indian Men More Vulnerable to Lung Cancer Than Women? Understanding the Gender Gap

Updated Nov 21, 2026 | 11:00 AM IST

SummaryLung cancer affects Indian men more frequently than women, but the gender gap goes beyond smoking habits. Explore the biological, environmental, occupational and lifestyle factors that may explain men's higher vulnerability.
Why Are Indian Men More Vulnerable to Lung Cancer Than Women? Understanding the Gender Gap

Credit: AI

Lung cancer is usually linked to smoking yet there is more to the tale behind who gets the disease in India. More men suffer from lung cancer than women. This does not happen by coincidence because of the differences in the number of smokers.

According to the Global Cancer Observatory (GLOBOCAN 2022), lung cancer is one of the most common cancers among Indian males. There is a substantial difference in the prevalence rate of cancer between men and women, and the former group bears a higher burden of the disease. One needs to go deeper into the problem to find an explanation.

Difference in tobacco consumption patterns

Tobacco consumption is one of the most important factors influencing the likelihood of suffering from cancer. Traditionally, smoking was a practice more common among men in India. According to the results of the Global Adult Tobacco Survey (GATS-2, 2016-17), about 24 per cent of Indian men had ever consumed tobacco, compared to just 14 per cent of women.

Cigarette smoke and bidis contain harmful chemicals that cause gradual damage to the tissues lining the airways. Such repeated exposure makes changes in genes more probable, which ultimately results in the occurrence of cancer. Moreover, the risk becomes higher depending on the length and severity of smoking.

Also read: World COPD Day: Even As Delhi's Air Pollution Declines, These Overlooked Factors Can Raise Your COPD Risk

Occupational and environmental exposure are additional sources of risk factors

Gender differences in the workforce in India may contribute to additional exposure to cancer-causing substances as well. Male employees in such occupations as construction, mining, manufacturing, transportation and some industries may be exposed to asbestos, silica dust, diesel engine exhausts and other hazardous agents. As a result, they become at greater risk of developing lung cancer due to long-term exposure.

Air pollution may contribute to an increase in the risk of lung cancer as well. Inhalation of fine particulates, especially PM2.5, is able to penetrate deeply into the lungs and cause cancer. According to IARC, outdoor air pollution and particulate matter are carcinogenic to humans.

Nevertheless, women may suffer from environmental risk factors too. Inhalation of smoke caused by solid fuel combustion in kitchens with poor ventilation and passive exposure to cigarette smoke pose additional risks for female patients.

Also read: Lung Cancer Survival Improves By 71% In US: But 1 In 5 Patients Still Gets No Treatment

Why do women who have never smoked develop lung cancer?

One common myth is that lung cancer only affects smokers. Some women develop lung cancer without any history of smoking. Some lung cancers, especially some kinds of adenocarcinomas, occur in people with no past of smoking. These cancers could have unique features and genetic mutations that could assist in identifying targeted therapy for this condition.

This is why an individual assessment of each case of lung cancer is necessary rather than jumping to conclusions about what caused the cancer based on whether one smokes or not.

How late diagnosis can be dangerous

While men might disregard cough, shortness of breath, or chest pains as being results of smoking, pollution, or age, women might struggle with the same problem due to the fact that they do not smoke.

A persistent cough for weeks, bloody sputum, unintentional weight loss, constant chest pain, or an increasing level of breathlessness is never to be dismissed. Symptoms like these do not always mean cancer, yet they need a proper medical evaluation.

Gender differences in the incidence of lung cancer depend on behavioral, environmental, occupational, and biological factors. It is essential to stop smoking, create safe workplaces, reduce pollution of the air, and have an early diagnosis for both men and women.

Lung cancer cannot be viewed as a man's disease or the outcome of smoking. The chances might differ, but it needs to be universally recognized and treated.

End of Article

Can Well-Controlled Diabetes Still Affect Kidney Function Over Time?

Updated Nov 21, 2026 | 05:00 PM IST

SummaryEven when blood sugar levels are well controlled, people with diabetes may remain at risk of gradual kidney damage. Explore why this happens, the factors involved and how regular kidney screening can help detect early changes.
Can Well-Controlled Diabetes Still Affect Kidney Function Over Time?

Credit: iStock

Even if diabetes is kept under control kidney function can still get worse over time. Good control of blood sugar cuts the risk of kidney disease a lot but it does not remove the risk entirely.

The risk depends on things, such as how long one has had diabetes years of poor blood sugar control, high blood pressure being overweight genes and heart disease. Sometimes kidney damage that started when blood sugar was high before can keep showing up after blood sugar improves later.

Why HbA1c Alone Cannot Reveal Kidney Health

One key point is that HbA1c by itself does not show kidney health. A person may have a HbA1c of 6.5 percent yet still have early kidney damage with no signs. That is why regular kidney screening is vital.

I recommend two tests for every person with diabetes: urine albumin-to-creatinine ratio, called UACR and estimated glomerular filtration rate, called eGFR. These tests reveal kidney damage early before any symptoms. People with type 2 diabetes should have these tests at once a year.

Also read: Canada Approves Daily GLP-1 Pill As New Study Finds Drugs May Outperform Metformin In Diabetes Management

Lifestyle Changes And Regular Screening Can Protect Kidney Health

In addition to blood sugar control keeping blood pressure low staying at a healthy weight exercising often avoiding needless painkillers and quitting smoking are key ways to protect kidneys. New medicines, SGLT2 inhibitors and for some people, finerenone have shown strong kidney protection

Controlling blood sugar matters. Protecting kidneys needs more than just diabetes control. Regular screening and early treatment can greatly lower the chance of kidney disease and the need, for dialysis.

By Dr. Ronak Bhalodia, Dr NB Nephrology, MD Medicine, Sterling Hospital, Rajkot

End of Article