A carnivore diet is a restrictive diet that only includes meat, fish, and other animal products like dairy and eggs. More recently, it has been brought into the limelight by influencers and social media personalities. In fact, there is a whole community of "meatfluencer" who are sharing their meat-eating plans. One of them is Dr Paul Saladino MD, whose belief that there was no better way to prevent chronic diseases than a carnivore diet prompted him to write books and post videos regarding the same. He believed so much in this eating plan that he became a go-to person for many following the same plan, until recently, when he decided to quit.

Here Are Seven Reasons Why He Decided To Quit

Carnivore Diet Disrupted His Sleep

Switching to an all-meat diet isn't always straightforward, especially when it comes to digestion—a lesson Dr Saladino learned firsthand. He experienced sleep disturbances, likely due to the difficulty of digesting high-protein meals. Since protein takes longer to break down, it demands more energy from the body, which can interfere with rest.

According to Johns Hopkins Medicine, digestion slows by up to 50% during sleep. Additionally, many types of meat contain tyramine, a compound derived from the amino acid tyrosine. Increased tyramine intake can lead to health issues and also triggers the release of norepinephrine, a hormone that raises heart rate and blood pressure, making restful sleep harder to achieve.

He also experienced hypnagogic jerks—sudden muscle spasms that jolt the body awake. "I would fall asleep but then jerk myself awake like I was falling multiple times. It was stressful and traumatic, leading to poor sleep," he shared in his YouTube video.

Eating Only Meat May Have Triggered Heart Palpitations

Another concerning side effect Dr Saladino experienced was heart palpitations—episodes where his heart felt like it was racing or fluttering. While stress is a common cause, few would immediately link palpitations to meat consumption.

However, a sudden shift to an all-meat diet can lead to electrolyte imbalances. The elimination of carbohydrates lowers insulin levels, prompting the kidneys to excrete more sodium. This disrupts the balance of essential minerals like potassium and magnesium, which are crucial for heart function.

Muscle Cramps Became Persistent

Dr Saladino also suffered from frequent muscle cramps while following the carnivore diet. In a post on X, he emphasized the importance of maintaining adequate magnesium, calcium, and potassium levels to prevent cramping. He initially believed that animal-based foods provided sufficient minerals, but his ongoing cramps led him to reconsider.

"I started to think maybe long-term ketosis is not great for me,” he admitted on the *More Plates More Dates* podcast. “Probably not a great thing for most humans."

His Testosterone Levels Dropped Significantly

Dr Saladino also saw a decline in his testosterone levels after following the carnivore diet for over a year. "At the beginning of my carnivore experiment, my testosterone was about 800. After a year to a year and a half, it had dropped to around 500," he revealed.

The issue likely stems from excessive protein intake, which can elevate inflammation and disrupt hormone levels. A 2022 study published in Nutrition and Health found that consuming more than 35% of daily calories from protein can lead to various negative effects, including reduced testosterone.

He Had Chronically Low Insulin Levels

Because he largely eliminated carbohydrates—except for a small amount of fruit—Dr Saladino developed persistently low blood sugar. In his YouTube video, he explained, "I had very low insulin because I wasn’t eating carbohydrates, and the protein I consumed wasn’t insulinogenic enough."

While some diabetics report improved blood sugar control on the carnivore diet, its effects vary based on individual metabolic responses. For non-diabetics, low insulin can lead to hypoglycemia, causing symptoms like dizziness, confusion, a racing heart, and, in extreme cases, seizures or coma. Mild cases can be managed with fast-acting carbohydrates like juice or candy, but severe episodes require medical attention.

His Blood Test Results Showed Concerning Imbalances

Lab tests revealed that his magnesium levels were low, while his sex hormone-binding globulin (SHBG) was elevated—both potential red flags for long-term health issues.

A magnesium deficiency can cause numbness, tingling, fatigue, nausea, headaches, and muscle cramps. Since cramps often strike at night, low magnesium may also contribute to sleep disturbances.

High SHBG levels indicate an excess of circulating protein in the blood, which can increase the risk of heart disease, osteoporosis, and depression. To counteract these imbalances, introducing more magnesium-rich foods—such as leafy greens, nuts, beans, and yogurt—could be beneficial.

He Felt Cold All The Time

Electrolyte imbalances and metabolic disruptions can even affect body temperature, which Dr. Saladino experienced firsthand. "I was always cold,"he shared in his YouTube video.

Upon testing his thyroid function, he discovered that his total T3 and free T3 hormone levels were "not ideal." These hormones regulate metabolism, and low levels can slow down metabolic processes, leading to cold intolerance.

Holding urine occasionally, such as during a long meeting or traffic jam, is generally not harmful for most healthy adults. However, repeatedly delaying urination for extended periods may affect urinary health, particularly in people who are prone to urinary tract infections (UTIs) or have existing bladder problems.

What Happens When You Hold Urine for Too Long?

When urine remains in the bladder for too long, it can become uncomfortable and may contribute to bladder overdistension. In some individuals, particularly those with underlying urinary retention or bladder dysfunction, regularly postponing urination may worsen existing problems.

While holding urine does not directly cause a UTI in every case, incomplete bladder emptying can increase the risk of infection.

Also read: Are People With CKD At Higher Risk Of Dementia And Cognitive Problems?

Why You Should Not Reduce Water Intake to Avoid Bathroom Break

People who work long hours or commute frequently should try to respond to the urge to urinate rather than routinely suppressing it.

Maintaining adequate hydration is equally important, as deliberately drinking less water to avoid bathroom breaks can lead to concentrated urine and may increase the risk of certain urinary problems like concentrated urine leading to crystallization and stone formation.

When Should You Seek Medical Advice?

If you experience persistent urgency, burning during urination, lower abdominal discomfort, difficulty passing urine or blood in the urine, seek medical advice. Developing regular bathroom habits and ensuring convenient access to washrooms can help support long-term urinary health.

It is also important to recognise when urinary symptoms may indicate a more serious problem. Inability to pass urine despite a strong urge, particularly when accompanied by severe lower abdominal pain or swelling, requires urgent medical attention.

Fever, chills or pain in the back or side alongside urinary symptoms may indicate a kidney infection and should be assessed promptly. Avoid assuming that such symptoms are simply the result of holding urine for too long.

By Dr. Vikram Kalra, Principal Director - Nephrology and Kidney Transplant, Aakash Healthcare Multi Speciality Hospital, Dwarka

Menopause brings several changes to a woman’s body, and the breasts are no exception. As levels of oestrogen and other hormones decline, the glandular tissue in the breasts gradually decreases and is replaced by fatty tissue. This can change how the breasts look and feel.

For many women, breasts may become softer, less firm or change slightly in size and shape after menopause. Loss of skin elasticity with age can also contribute to changes in breast shape.

These changes can be a normal part of aging. But not every breast change after menopause should be attributed to hormones.

What breast changes can happen after menopause?

The hormonal changes associated with menopause can alter the composition of breast tissue. Some women may notice that their breasts feel softer or less dense than they did before menopause. Changes in skin elasticity can also lead to sagging or a gradual change in breast shape.

These changes, by themselves, are generally not a cause for alarm.

The concern arises when a new, unusual or persistent change appears, particularly if it is different from what a woman has experienced before.

Also read: Could A Daily Pill Help Prevent Breast Cancer Recurrence? Roche's Promising Experimental Drug Awaits FDA Approval

Which breast changes should not be ignored?

After menopause, women should speak to a doctor if they notice:

• A new change in the size or shape of one breast
• A new lump or area of thickening in the breast
• Persistent swelling in the breast
• Dimpling, puckering or thickening of the breast skin
• A newly inverted or retracted nipple
• Unusual nipple discharge, particularly if it contains blood
• A change in the appearance of the nipple or areola
• A new lump or swelling in the armpit or near the collarbone

These signs do not necessarily mean that cancer is present. Several benign breast conditions can cause similar changes. However, they should not be self-diagnosed or automatically dismissed as a consequence of menopause.

What about breast pain?

Breast pain is commonly caused by benign conditions and, before menopause, may also be associated with hormonal fluctuations. After menopause, persistent or unexplained breast pain should nevertheless be discussed with a doctor, particularly if it occurs alongside another breast change.

It is also important to remember that the absence of pain does not rule out breast cancer. Many breast cancers do not cause pain, and some may not produce a lump that can be felt.

This is one reason women should not wait for pain or a clearly palpable lump before seeking medical advice when they notice something unusual.

Is breast cancer screening necessary after menopause?

Screening remains an important part of breast health after menopause, but the appropriate approach depends on factors such as age, family history, personal medical history and individual risk.

Women should discuss screening with their healthcare provider and follow recommendations appropriate to their age and risk profile. Every woman should also learn how to perform a self-breast examination and become familiar with the normal look and feel of her breasts. Regular self-examination can help women notice new or unusual changes early and seek medical advice promptly.

Self-breast examination should complement, rather than replace, recommended screening and clinical evaluation. If a woman notices a new lump, skin change, nipple change or any other unusual finding, she should consult a doctor even if her routine screening is due later.

Those with a strong family history of breast or ovarian cancer, or a known genetic predisposition to breast cancer, may require a different or more intensive screening strategy.

Importantly, screening is intended for women who do not have symptoms. If a woman notices a new breast change, she should not simply wait for her next routine screening appointment; she should discuss the change with a doctor.

Also read: Breast Cancer: Are Women in India Being Diagnosed Too Late?

Don't blame every change on menopause

Menopause is a natural stage of life, but it should not become an explanation for every new symptom.

Most breast changes are not cancerous. However, the only way to determine the cause of a persistent or suspicious change is through appropriate medical evaluation.

Women should become familiar with how their breasts normally look and feel and pay attention to changes that are new or unusual for them.

Breast health does not become less important after menopause. In fact, continuing to pay attention to changes, practising regular self-breast examination and staying up to date with appropriate screening can help detect problems early.

The message is not to fear every change, but to avoid ignoring one simply because menopause has begun. When something feels or looks different, getting it checked is always better than assuming it is “just menopause.”

By Dr. Tapti Sen, Sr. Consultant ,Breast Surgery, RG Stone Urology & Laparoscopy Hospital, Kolkata

Many women notice changes in their breasts, such as localised tenderness, an itchy nipple or a slight pulling of the skin. These changes are often caused by benign conditions, including hormonal changes, irritation or infection.

Breast cancer does not always present as a painless lump, however. It can sometimes appear in less typical ways, and recognising persistent or unexplained changes can help people seek timely assessment.

India’s breast cancer burden

GLOBOCAN 2022 estimates recorded 192,020 new breast cancer cases and 98,337 deaths in India in 2022. These estimates placed India third globally for the number of new cases and first for the absolute number of deaths. These are estimates for 2022, not current annual counts.

Changes in skin, shape and nipple

A tumour can involve the breast’s supporting fibrous structures and surrounding tissues, causing skin tethering, dimpling or a new change in breast shape or symmetry. Any new, unexplained change deserves clinical assessment.

Changes in the nipple also deserve attention. A nipple that newly flattens, turns inward or deviates to one side should be assessed. Spontaneous discharge from one nipple—particularly bloody or clear discharge—can be a warning sign, although it is not always caused by cancer. Persistent itching, burning, flaking or eczema-like crusting of the nipple may be associated with Paget’s disease of the breast, a rare malignancy involving the nipple–areola complex that is often associated with an underlying breast carcinoma.

Unexplained swelling or persistent lumps in the armpit or above the collarbone can sometimes be an early sign of breast cancer. These findings also have non-cancerous causes and need assessment rather than self-diagnosis.

Also read: Why Peak Incidence For Breast Cancer In India Occurs Between Ages 40–50, Compared To 60–70 In The US & Europe

Pain, redness and swelling

Breast cancer can be painful, even though pain alone is not a reliable way to tell whether a change is cancerous. A painful lump should not be ignored, and a painless lump should not be assumed to be harmless.

Inflammatory breast cancer can be particularly difficult to recognise. It may cause rapid breast enlargement, heaviness, redness, warmth and swelling, sometimes without a distinct lump. The skin may develop a pitted appearance resembling orange peel. Because these symptoms can resemble mastitis or other skin conditions, infection may initially be suspected. However, persistent or worsening redness and swelling, especially when symptoms do not improve as expected with treatment, require prompt reassessment and investigation for an underlying malignancy.

How the diagnosis is confirmed

Any persistent or suspicious breast change warrants clinical assessment. Depending on the person’s age and symptoms, evaluation may include diagnostic mammography and targeted ultrasound. Further imaging or biopsy may be needed when indicated. A suspicious finding should not be dismissed solely because initial imaging is reassuring.

Persistent or suspicious nipple and skin changes require timely specialist assessment. If Paget’s disease or another malignancy is suspected, biopsy may be necessary without a trial of topical treatment. Suspected inflammatory breast cancer requires prompt imaging and tissue diagnosis; a skin punch biopsy may also be indicated.

Also read: Breast Cancer in Young Women: What You Should Know

Common causes of delay

People may delay seeking help because they expect a symptom to become painful, hope it will go away, or assume that redness or itching is due to irritation. Breast symptoms other than a lump can also be associated with longer diagnostic journeys. The length of delay varies between individuals and healthcare settings, so precise comparisons should be interpreted in the context of the study and the interval it measures.

Repeatedly treating persistent skin redness or nipple crusting with antibiotics, moisturisers or steroid ointments without reassessment can delay appropriate investigation. Treatment may be reasonable when infection or a skin condition is suspected, but symptoms that persist, recur or worsen need further evaluation.

When to seek medical advice

A new breast lump, unexplained skin dimpling, new nipple inversion, spontaneous bloody discharge, or persistent redness and swelling warrants prompt medical assessment. Unexplained fullness or swelling in the armpit or above the collarbone should also be checked. Most breast changes are benign, but symptoms should not be ignored or self-treated indefinitely. A healthcare professional can decide whether imaging, biopsy or other investigations are needed.

Early assessment can improve the chance of diagnosing breast cancer at a treatable stage. In general, breast cancer diagnosed while localised has a better prognosis than disease that has spread to distant parts of the body, although outcomes also depend on tumour biology, treatment, and other clinical factors.

By Dr. Arun Kumar Sharma, Consultant, Surgical Oncology, Fortis Hospital Jalandhar