There Is An 'Overdiagnosis' Of Mental Health Issues In UK, Says Wes Streeting

Wes Streeting, the UK's Health Secretary, recently sparked controversy by saying that there are certain mental health conditions that are being overdiagnosed. In an interview with BBC's One's Sunday with Laura Kussenberg, he expressed his concerns that too many people are being "written off" due to mental health diagnoses. This could potentially prevent them from re-entering the workforce. He also however suggested that early intervention could help the people to stay employed and that over diagnosis of mental health conditions may be causing unnecessary dependence on welfare benefits.

His comments came amid discussions on potential government reforms to Personal Independence Payment (PIP) and other disability benefits. Furthermore, it is during this time when in the US, health sector is undergoing major changes, and important issues like mental health is sidelined. In such a scenario, Streeting's comment did not sit right with the people.

His remarks have rather drawn criticism from mental health professionals and advocacy groups who have argued that such rhetoric risks stigmatize mental health conditions and discourages people from seeking help.

What The Experts Say?

Minesh Patel, Associate Director of Policy and Campaigns at the mental health charity Mind, acknowledged the need for better support but warned against language that undermines legitimate medical diagnoses. He pointed out that individuals applying for benefits already undergo rigorous assessments, with many initial denials later overturned at appeal.

Robert Howard, a professor of old age psychiatry at University College London, expressed concerns that Streeting’s statements could be used to justify reductions in mental health funding. He emphasized that rather than questioning diagnoses, the government should focus on ensuring timely and effective treatment. Howard also highlighted that many young people with anxiety and other conditions struggle to work, and the best way to support them is through accessible psychological therapy—not by suggesting they are not truly ill.

Is Mental Health Really Overdiagnosed?

This topic has always been a heated one, and has been the heart of debates. Some studies suggest that mental health diagnoses have increased in the recent years. However, experts argue that this is due to the greater awareness and improved access to mental health help and resources. The approach too have been better, where people are now more open about talking it. Media too has made a mark by producing films and documentaries around it. capturing what it looks like. documenting the experiences, and thus allowing a discourse.

A 2022 study published in The Lancet Psychiatry found that while there has been a rise in diagnoses of anxiety and depression, this correlates with increasing societal stressors such as economic uncertainty and social isolation. The study emphasized that proper mental health support can significantly improve employment outcomes, contradicting the notion that overdiagnosis is a widespread issue.

Similarly, a report from the UK’s National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) found that many individuals with mental health conditions still face delays in receiving treatment. This suggests that the issue is not overdiagnosis but rather an inadequate response to growing mental health needs. Moreover, research from the British Journal of Psychiatry has shown that underdiagnosis remains a bigger concern, particularly among marginalized groups who may not have access to appropriate care.

Experts warn that Streeting’s comments could inadvertently discourage people from seeking help or lead policymakers to introduce stricter benefit eligibility criteria, making it harder for those with genuine mental health struggles to receive the necessary support.